One score out of 100 for everything, built from every poll pick, ranking, tier placement, rating, swipe and matchup on Rateify. Ratings and tier placements count full; comparisons like matchups count for less, because they depend on what something was up against.
Everything starts at 50 and moves as votes come in: around 15 votes the score is mostly real opinion, and by ~50 it barely remembers the starting point. Things need 5 votes to be listed at all — below that the score is still mostly the starting 50, so it wouldn't mean anything.